Dave Davidson • May 21, 2025

Replacing a Cracked Tub? Here Are Your Best Style Options

A cracked bathtub isn’t just an eyesore—it can lead to water damage, mold, and even structural issues over time. If you’re facing this situation, it’s the perfect opportunity to reimagine your bathroom with a new tub or even convert to a walk-in shower. At Dave Davidson Remodeling, we help homeowners turn problems into upgrades, combining function with a fresh new look.


In this guide, we’ll walk you through the best replacement options and style ideas for your new tub or shower. Whether you want a quick swap or a full renovation, you’ll find a solution that fits your space and style.



Should You Replace the Tub or Switch to a Walk-In Shower?


New Walk-In Shower

Before you dive into product styles, the first decision is whether you want another bathtub—or if a walk-in shower might suit your needs better.


A new bathtub makes sense if your household enjoys soaking or you have young children. On the other hand, a walk-in shower offers easy access, a modern look, and can make a small bathroom feel more open. It’s a popular choice for homeowners planning to age in place or simplify their space.


Top Tub Styles for Your Remodel


If you’re leaning toward a new tub, there are several styles to choose from, each with its own look and function:


  • Alcove Tub: Installed in a three-wall nook, this is the most common style and great for small bathrooms.

  • Freestanding Tub: Stylish and dramatic, these tubs stand alone and work well in larger spaces.

  • Drop-In Tub: Designed to be placed into a framed enclosure, allowing for custom finishes around the tub.

  • Corner Tub: Ideal for maximizing unused corners, these tubs can add luxury to compact spaces.

  • Whirlpool or Air Tub: Perfect for relaxation, these tubs include jets or air systems for a spa-like experience.

Each option offers something different, from space-saving practicality to high-end comfort.


Walk-In Shower Designs to Consider


Walk-in showers are growing in popularity thanks to their modern style and ease of use.

Here are some design ideas that work well in any updated bathroom:


  • Frameless glass doors for a sleek, open look

  • Built-in bench seating for comfort and function

  • Recessed niches for storing shampoo and soap

  • Slip-resistant tile flooring for added safety

  • Rainfall shower-heads or dual-shower systems

Walk-in showers also allow for more flexible layouts and are easier to clean than a traditional tub.


Not Sure Which Option Is Right for You?


Talk to Dave Directly: Book a free consultation to walk through your options with Dave Davidson Remodeling. We’ll help you compare layouts, styles, and costs to find the best fit for your bathroom.


Factors to Consider Before Choosing


There are a few things to keep in mind when deciding between a new tub and a walk-in shower:

  • Space: Tubs require more room horizontally, while walk-in showers can be customized to fit tight spaces.

  • Lifestyle: Households with kids may prefer a tub, while older homeowners often lean toward showers.

  • Resale: Having at least one bathtub can appeal to future buyers.

  • Budget: Tubs can be more affordable up front, while custom walk-in showers may add more value in the long run.

Turn a Cracked Tub Into a Fresh Start


A cracked tub doesn’t have to be a setback. It’s a chance to update your space with something more stylish, more functional, and built to last. Whether you want a deep soaker tub or a modern, barrier-free shower, Dave Davidson Remodeling can bring your vision to life.


Let us help you choose the best upgrade for your home and make your bathroom feel brand new again.